Martin Gardner

photo from the Oberwolfach Photo Collection

photo from the Oberwolfach Photo Collection

Martin Gardner was best known for his

*Mathematical Games*column in Scientific American from 1956 to 1981. He stopped writing the column before I was even born, but others carried on his legacy. In the 1980s Douglas Hofstadter (the famous author of GEB) took over with with his

*Metamagical Themas*column, and afterwards Ian Stewart (a professional mathematician) continued the tradition with

*Mathematical Recreations*.

Ian Stewart's wonderful column ran from 1990 to 2001, when I was just the right age to become hooked -- I probably read every one of Ian Stewart's articles after 1995. When I got to college, some of my friends pointed me to the earlier columns of Martin Gardner, and I quickly became a fan. It was not hard to me to see why Ron Graham said of him, "Martin has turned thousands of children into mathematicians and thousands of mathematicians into children." I'm sure that I owe some of my love for puzzles to Martin Gardner's legacy, and I was very sad to hear of his passing.

It would only be appropriate to end this post with a puzzle. Martin Gardner really liked this one and named it the "Impossible Puzzle."

Let x and y be two different integers. Both x and y are greater than 1, and their sum is at most 100. Sally is given only their sum, and Paul is given only their product. Sally and Paul are honest and all this is commonly known to both of them.

The following conversation now takes place:

What are these numbers?

- Paul: I do not know the two numbers.
- Sally: I knew that already.
- Paul: Now I know the two numbers.
- Sally: Now I know them also.

No cheating! I will update this post with the solution in a couple days.

A good memorial and an obituary of Martin Gardner.

The writer of the current Scientific American puzzle column,

*Puzzling Adventures*, is Dennis Shasha.

**Update (5/30/10)**: The answer is that the two numbers are 4 and 13. I might have written up a solution if good ones (including Martin Gardner's) didn't appear here.

the solution doesn't appear "there".

ReplyDeleteis it sth like:

Paul get a number p=(a^2)b. where a and b are prime integers.

Then Sally may get number s=a+ab or s=a^2+b

check (i, s-i), for all i=2, 3, ...., |_s/2_|

make sure one can find only one case that i*(s-i)=(c^2)d, where c and d are prime integers.

is this right?